Cinnamon Sugar Bread Pudding (Cute Older Recipes Are Modern Day Gems)

March 25, 2019
Cinnamon Sugar Bread Pudding (Cute Older Recipes Are Modern Day Gems) - I’ve done bread pudding many, many ways over the years. Definitely a winner!

“This, Grandma.  This was the best day ever”  ~ Love, Eli

(This post may contain affiliate links)

Jump to Recipe

This past week, my daughter and grandsons came to Iowa for a visit.  I can’t even tell you how wonderful it was to see them and how much they’ve been missed.

After spending the day, I came home happy and sticky, with spaghetti sauce in my hair and blue ice cream handprints on my sweater

It was fun to hear (in person) about kindergarten, learning to ride a bike, and of course, all of the things he loves to eat.  Macaroni and cheese, chicken nuggets, tomato soup, and ..

cinnamon sugar toast

(A man after my own heart)

And so .. a story

My mom died unexpectedly when I was thirteen.  I don’t have many photos of her .. but in the one I like most, I’m almost two and she’s holding me.  I love her hair.

I can’t imagine having a little one, plus all of the things she had to manage around our family’s farm, and having hair that good.  Today I have only a kitty, a day job, and most of the time I feel like my hair leaves much to be desired

A number of years after she was gone, we divvied up the last of her belongings.  Her recipe book is the thing I remember most.  It was dark green, sturdy, and filled with index cards and newspaper clippings.  Before entrusting it to my brother, our step-mom hired my daughter to transcribe the recipes.

A dollar for each

I remember how much fun it was flipping through them, finding, in her handwriting, not only recipes, but menu ideas jotted on slips of yellowing paper.  She served an awful lot of jello salads

We also found this recipe, of sorts, and I have to type it up for you exactly as it was written because it would be a shame not to share its wisdom:

Recipe for Happiness

2 heaping cups of patience

1 heartful of love

3 handsful of generosity

dash of laughter

1 headful of understanding

Sprinkle generously with kindness

Add plenty of faith and mix well.  Spread over a period of a lifetime

Cinnamon Sugar Bread Pudding (Cute Older Recipes Are Modern Day Gems) - I’ve done bread pudding many, many ways over the years. Definitely a winner!

I also remember running across and really studying, her recipe for Cinnamon Sugar Toast.  Comfort food that, to this day, invokes great amounts of nostalgia.

I mean, how could something so simple require a recipe?  Toasted bread, covered with a thin layer of butter and a dusting of cinnamon and sugar.  Come to find out, there was far more than met the eye

The secret?

A generous coating of melted butter on both sides of the bread.  Afterward, it was dredged in cinnamon sugar before being cut into triangles and baked until crisp.  The toast was crispy and crunchy.  The butter made it rich.  The cinnamon sugar caramelized lightly, turning almost lacy at the edges

No wonder hers were so good!

In the margins, a note about keeping them in a tin on the counter, where she promised, they would only get better with age.  One could eat them like cookies

Cinnamon Sugar Bread Pudding (Cute Older Recipes Are Modern Day Gems) - I’ve done bread pudding many, many ways over the years. Definitely a winner!

I hadn’t thought about her cinnamon sugar toast in the longest time

That is until last summer when I spent a lot of time, staying with a friend.  On her kitchen counter lived one of her favorites .. a twenty-year-old Gourmet cookbook, written for people who love farmers markets.  Those of us who happily wander the streets of our cities and come upon places where the air smells of peaches and corn and farmers sell fruits and veggies they harvested only hours earlier

The cookbook had been a going-away gift from a group of co-workers, and inside was a recipe for an apple and cheddar bread pudding that’s pretty incredible

I’ve made (and enjoyed) bread pudding many, many ways over the years.  And it’s nearly always good.  But from this day forward, if I’m lucky enough to have you over to my place for dinner, and bread pudding seems like it might be a nice finish to the meal, this is the recipe I’ll be using

Cinnamon Sugar Bread Pudding (Cute Older Recipes Are Modern Day Gems) - I’ve done bread pudding many, many ways over the years. Definitely a winner!

For some, classic cinnamon sugar toast is sufficient to make the day feel a little bit decadent, if not exceptional.  For others, it’s casserole-style or bust because baking it in one big pan is vastly more enjoyable than toasting, buttering, and sprinkling on repeat.  Especially when people who aren’t cooking come by and steal slices before you’re able to sit down.

I’m also going to make the argument that once you have Brit-style bread pudding casserole, uplifted by the tiniest step that is buttering and sprinkling the bread before fanning in out in a pan

there’s no other way

Cinnamon Sugar Bread Pudding (Cute Older Recipes Are Modern Day Gems) - I’ve done bread pudding many, many ways over the years. Definitely a winner!

Cinnamon Sugar Bread Pudding (Cute Older Recipes Are Modern Day Gems) - I’ve done bread pudding many, many ways over the years. Definitely a winner!

A few notes about the recipe

When it comes to bread puddings, there’s a temptation to make them complex.  After all, it’s hard to argue with vanilla beans, brandy-soaked raisins, salted caramel, heavy cream, and brioche.  They certainly have their place.  At the same time, it’s nice to know that you can make something exceptional using whatever sandwich bread is in the pantry and ingredients you already have in your fridge.

Non-dairy milk will work well here, as will breads that are rich, but I don’t find the latter necessary to serve something luxurious.

True confessions?  The recipe my mom used all those years ago was a bit frightening when I thought about how much butter and sugar were on a little piece of bread.  Here, you can definitely go easy when spreading and sprinkling.  And one side will do the trick

If it helps, remind yourself that this isn’t breakfast.  This is a cookie.  Make it your mantra



~ Adapted from Gourmet’s Fresh: From the Farmer’s Market to Your Kitchen 

Cinnamon Sugar Bread Pudding With Apples and Cheddar


  • 14 slices bread ~ 1 lb (I used gluten-free, but any kind of bread will be great)
  • ½ cup butter, softened, divided
  • ¾ cup natural sugar, such as Sugar in the Raw or turbinado, divided
  • 1 ½ tsp cinnamon
  • ½ tsp nutmeg
  • 3 pounds medium to large-sized apples ( ~ 6 or 7)
  • 1 ½ Tbsp fresh lemon juice
  • ½ cup packed light brown sugar
  • ¼ cup water
  • 1 cup extra-sharp Cheddar, grated (~ 4 ounces)
  • 4 eggs large or XL
  • 2 ¾ cups milk
  • ¼ tsp salt


  • Prep
  • Preheat oven to 350°F
  • Butter a 13x9 inch (or equivalent) baking dish

  • Cinnamon Sugar Toasts
  • Butter the bread slices thinly on one side and arrange on baking sheets
  • In a small bowl combine the cinnamon, nutmeg, and 1/4 cup of the natural sugar
  • Sprinkle evenly over the buttered sides of the bread
  • Toast in batches until just golden-brown (~ 15 minutes)
  • Cool the cinnamon sugar toast on racks and quarter each slice into triangles, reserving 24 triangles

  • Apples
  • In the meantime, peel, quarter, and core the apples
  • Cut them lengthwise into thin slices before tossing them in a bowl with lemon juice
  • In a large heavy skillet over medium heat, melt the remaining 1/2 stick of butter with the brown sugar.
  • Add the apples and water
  • Cook, covered, stirring occasionally for about ten minutes
  • Remove the lid and continue to cook the apples until just tender and most of the liquid has evaporated (~ 5 minutes more)

  • Bread Pudding
  • Arrange a layer of cinnamon sugar toasts in the baking dish, breaking triangles to fit where needed
  • Spoon half of the apple mixture evenly over the toasts and sprinkle evenly with 1/2 cup cheddar.
  • Top with another layer of cinnamon toasts and the remaining apple mixture
  • Arrange reserved toasts, sugared sides up, overlapping slightly, in a ring around the edge of the dish
  • In a bowl whisk together eggs, remaining 1/2 cup natural sugar, milk, and salt
  • Pour slowly and evenly over apples.
  • Chill the pudding, covered, at least 1 hour and up to 1 day.
  • Cover with foil and bake the pudding in middle of oven 30 minutes.
  • Remove the foil, sprinkle remaining 1/2 cup cheese evenly over top and bake another 15 minutes
  • Check for doneness and, if needed bake a little longer. (I usually have to cook it another ten minutes or so. If it's not quite done, but the top is looking really dark, put the foil back on for this last iteration)

Serves: 12
Nutrition + Show
Calories 372
Total Fat 12.6g
Saturated Fat 6.9g
Carbohydrates 58.3g
Fiber 5.6g
Sugars 37.5g
Protein 9.7g
Print This Recipe


You Might Also Like

1 Comment

  • Reply Abby June 16, 2019 at 2:17 am

    Wow I really need to get on here more often! This was so awesome to read and made me smile. First, those pictures of you and Eli are so precious and I KNOW he had so much fun that day.. Ezrah , not so much but we made it through. Haha. Second, I have never seen a picture of your mom or you as a baby. I can’t really see her face but I think you definitely have her smile and it looks like I got her hair (wink wink) 🙂
    Ps. Did you know they make a pre-made cinnamon sugar now ? You can find it right by the cinnamon . And guess what ? I have 2 of them in my kitchen right now and they are used on the daily.

  • Leave a Reply

    Recipe Rating